PURLIN AUTOMATION / BLOG / Industrial motion
Industrial motion

Electric vs Pneumatic vs Hydraulic Actuators: Which Should You Use?

By Purlin Automation Engineering Team3 min read
Electric vs Pneumatic vs Hydraulic Actuators: Which Should You Use?

Pneumatic and hydraulic cylinders have moved machines for decades, and they still have their place. But for many jobs an electric linear actuator is simpler to install, cheaper to run and easier to control. Here is an honest comparison to help you decide.

Key points
  • Electric: no compressor, no leaks
  • Pneumatic: fast and simple end-to-end
  • Hydraulic: very high force, more upkeep

How each one works

  • Electric linear actuator: a DC motor turns a gearbox and lead screw, which pushes a rod in and out. It needs only a power cable and a control signal.
  • Pneumatic cylinder: compressed air pushes a piston. It needs a compressor, air lines, filters, regulators and valves.
  • Hydraulic cylinder: pressurised oil pushes a piston. It needs a pump, tank, hoses, valves and oil maintenance.

Side-by-side comparison

ElectricPneumaticHydraulic
ForceLow to high (Purlin: 100–8000 N)Low to mediumVery high
SpeedSlow to fast (3–400 mm/sec)Very fastSlow to medium
Position controlEasy, any point in the strokeMainly end to endPossible, with servo valves
Holding positionHolds when power is off (self-locking screw)Drifts if air leaksCan drift through valve leakage
InstallationPower cable onlyCompressor and air linesPump, tank and hoses
Energy useOnly while movingCompressor runs and leaks waste energyPump losses
MaintenanceVery lowLeaks, filters, water drainOil, seals, leaks
CleanlinessCleanClean but noisy exhaustOil leak risk
Duty cycleLimited (Purlin standard: 10%)ContinuousContinuous

Where electric actuators win

  • Machines that move occasionally and hold a position: beds, desks, recliners, hatches, dampers, solar trackers and adjustable fixtures.
  • Anywhere without compressed air: outdoor sites, mobile equipment, homes and hospitals.
  • Applications that need accurate or repeatable positions: with a feedback signal, an electric actuator can stop at any point in its stroke.
  • Clean environments: food handling, medical and office use, where oil or air exhaust is unwelcome.

Where pneumatics or hydraulics are still better

  • Very fast, continuous cycling, such as a pick-and-place pusher moving every two seconds all shift. Pneumatics is simple and has no duty cycle limit.
  • Very high forces beyond what a compact electric actuator can give, such as presses and heavy earth-moving equipment, where hydraulics is the normal choice.
  • Plants that already have compressed air and need a simple end-to-end motion.

The real cost: running, not buying

An air cylinder is often cheaper to buy than an electric actuator. But compressed air is one of the most expensive forms of energy in a factory: the compressor must run continuously to keep pressure, and small leaks waste energy all day. An electric actuator only uses power while it moves and holds its position for free. Over a few years, total cost often favours electric, especially for low-cycle applications.

Thinking of switching?

When replacing a cylinder with an electric actuator, check three things: the peak force, the cycle time (does it fit within the duty cycle?) and the mounting dimensions. Our selection guide article walks through the sizing, and our team can check your cycle times. Send us the cylinder size, air pressure and cycle and we will suggest a matching model.

Products mentioned in this article

Made in Bengaluru. Click a product for full specifications, drawings and datasheets.

Frequently asked questions

Is an electric actuator better than a pneumatic cylinder?

For applications that move occasionally, need to hold a position or have no compressed air supply, electric actuators are usually simpler and cheaper to run. For very fast continuous cycling, pneumatics is often better.

Do electric linear actuators hold position when the power is off?

Most lead-screw actuators are self-locking, so they hold their position without power. Pneumatic cylinders can drift when air leaks.

Can an electric actuator replace a hydraulic cylinder?

Yes, when the force is within the electric actuator's rating. Purlin actuators go up to 8000 N. Very high-force applications still usually need hydraulics.

Share: WhatsApp LinkedIn Facebook X Email
Need help choosing an actuator?

Send us your load, stroke, speed and how often it moves. Our engineers in Bengaluru will recommend a model and send a quotation.

Send an inquiry

More from the blog

Send an enquiry Chat on WhatsApp Follow on Instagram Watch on YouTube